BeerSmith 2 Recipe Printout - http://www.beersmith.com
Recipe: Two Sides of the Schwartz
Brewer: Wick
Asst Brewer:
Style: Schwarzbier (Black Beer)
TYPE: All Grain
Taste: (30.0)
Recipe Specifications
—————————————
Boil Size: 8.49 gal
Post Boil Volume: 6.24 gal
Batch Size (fermenter): 6.00 gal
Bottling Volume: 6.00 gal
Estimated OG: 1.055 SG
Estimated Color: 30.9 SRM
Estimated IBU: 28.6 IBUs
Brewhouse Efficiency: 72.00 %
Est Mash Efficiency: 72.0 %
Boil Time: 90 Minutes
Ingredients:
——————
Amt Name Type # %/IBU
7 lbs 0.9 oz Munich Malt (9.0 SRM) Grain 1 56.0 %
4 lbs 0.5 oz Pilsner (2 Row) Ger (2.0 SRM) Grain 2 32.0 %
8.1 oz Caramel/Crystal Malt - 40L (40.0 SRM) Grain 3 4.0 %
8.1 oz Chocolate Malt (450.0 SRM) Grain 4 4.0 %
4.0 oz Carafa II (412.0 SRM) Grain 5 2.0 %
4.0 oz Roasted Barley (300.0 SRM) Grain 6 2.0 %
1.50 oz Hallertauer [4.30 %] - Boil 90.0 min Hop 7 24.1 IBUs
0.50 oz Hallertauer [4.30 %] - Boil 20.0 min Hop 8 4.6 IBUs
0.50 oz Hallertauer [4.30 %] - Aroma Steep 0.0 m Hop 9 0.0 IBUs
2.0 pkg SafLager West European Lager (DCL/Fermen Yeast 10 -
Mash Schedule: Single Infusion, Medium Body, Batch Sparge
Total Grain Weight: 12 lbs 9.5 oz
——————————————
Name Description Step Temperat Step Time
Mash In Add 15.69 qt of water at 166.0 F 154.0 F 60 min
Sparge: Batch sparge with 2 steps (1.83gal, 4.25gal) of 168.0 F water
Notes:
———
Not a great brew day. After I dropped the hops in after I saw signs of a boil, I dropped the 60 minute hops in. So guess what. I hopped at 90 minutes. Oh well, followed the rest of the hop schedule in the recipe.
Pitched yeast sludge January 18th at 44 degrees.
January 20th fermentation chamber was at 55 degrees. Changed heat to cold and turned freezer back on and put to 48 degrees.
Created with BeerSmith 2 - http://www.beersmith.com
——————————————————————————————————————————-

I find chilling your wort a major time-consuming part of your brew day. I would say it takes at least an hour to get my wort down to pitching temperatures. Even longer in the summer time when groundwater temperature is higher than your pitching temperature. Like every beginning home brewer, I started with the ice bath method in my kitchen sink. This worked really well while I was extract-brewing and only boiling about 3 gallons of wort and topping off to my target volumes. I would chill my top off water in the refrigerator while brewing, use the ice bath to get to about 90 degrees, rack it to the carboy, and top off. That would get me to my pitching temps. Sometimes it would get me below pitching temps, so I had to wait for it to warm up.
This method was great, but when I decided to go all grain, I had to do full boils. So the idea of lugging 6 gallons of wort into the house and submerging that into an ice bath was not a very fun thought. The wife also didn’t like the idea of me bringing in 6 gallons of hot wort into the house and using a bathtub to chill wort.
So I went on a search for a wort chiller for a manageable price. I looked at all of the online home brew shops at all the different options. The top three methods I have found are immersion, plate, and counterflow chillers. All of them have their pros and cons.
Immersion Chiller
Pros: Affordable, easy to clean, wort does not run inside of your chiller, easy to sanitize, just drop it into your wort with about 15 minutes left in the boil.
Cons: Uses lots of water, and takes a long time to cool the wort.


Plate Chiller and Counterflow Chiller
I’m grouping this two together, because they seem to be essentially the same thing, in my opinion.
Pros: Can be gravity fed, uses less water than immersion, chilling less wort at any given moment.
Cons: To be really effective you would need a march pump, higher cost, hard to clean and sanitize. If you do not have a pump, you couldn’t pump boiling wort through it to sanitize, would need to use star san.
Well, what did I go with? Well not really wanting to buy a pump and all its fittings which will set you back at least 160 bucks, easy, I went with an immersion chiller. It was pretty easy choice since I found one for about $55 on eBay. Yes, it works great, but it wasn’t working great enough for me. So after listening to some podcasts and reading up on the Internet I found out using a pond pump with a bucket full of ice water would be helpful.

Pond Pump
You can pick up a cheap pond pump at Lowes for $20-$40 bucks. So add that to the cost of your immersion chiller and you’ll more than likely be around the same price as a plate or counterflow chiller. On brew day, I chill my wort down to 90-100 degrees with the patio hose. This normally takes 20-30 minutes, depending on how warm it is that day. Disconnect the hose from the immersion chiller and attach a tube from the pond pump to the immersion chiller then have it recirculate back into the bucket. Just replenish the ice into the bucket when it all melts and there ya go. Ice water is now pumping through your immersion chiller. I would say it takes another 20-30 minutes to get your wort to pitching temps. Now if you do not want to buy a pond pump, take your bottling bucket and fill it with ice water, put the bucket on, say, a step ladder and attach the bucket and chiller with a hose and let gravity do its thing. Have the chiller run off into another bucket and then just dump that water back into the ice bucket. That way you can make beer and get a great workout.
Last night I volunteered at a beer tasting in West Point. Anthony’s Good Food Market hosted the event. This sparked a question of mine. What does the Golden Triangle have to offer when Mississippi Craft Beer Week comes around? With last year as the inaugural year for MS Craft Beer Week, the GTR area has plenty of venues that are more than able to host these events. Who is willing?
The Halfway House: This is the newest beer-centered establishment in the area. Opened up with 30-plus taps and have room for expansion. Roomy inside, perfect outdoor patio. The beer menu is always changing, so you can experience something different every time you visit. The only negative is parking.
Rosey Baby Starkville: Rosey Baby has stepped up their game with 50-plus taps installed. Installed a cold room behind the bar to store kegs. It’s a nice setup for your average beer geek. They have hosted beer and wine tastings by certain breweries and wineries. Rosey Baby is doing their best to get into the mindset craft beer enthusiasts. Twitter: @RoseyBaby_stark
Dave’s Darkhorse Tavern: Want a low key environment, good live music and good beer? Dave’s is your place. While their selection isn’t anything like the others. The environment and live music makes this place a worth while host for any craft beer event in the area. They were the first place in the town with Sierra Nevada’s pale ale- even though it was in the bottle, there was not another bar in town where you could find it.
Ptolemy’s Taproom: When Ptolomey’s came into town it was the premier beer bar in Starkville. Started out with 12 taps and have upgraded to 20 taps. The venue is small, but it is located in the heart of Starkville’s Cotton District meaning you will get the college crowd to come and enjoy a beer with you. Twitter: @ptolemystaproom
The Princess Theater: The current owner, who enjoys a good craft beer, has taken on the task to make this bar quaint with plenty of beer selections on tap or in the bottle. Then there is also the theater next door that brings in musical acts. If you ever find yourself in Columbus, go to this historic location and have a beer. You’ll be pleased.
Anthony’s Good Food Market: Good food and good beer. Average number of taps, but have a great bottle selection. Great space by the bar and the room next to the bar. Firkin anyone? Influenced by the best beer store in the area right down the street, the Smokestack, the writing is on the wall. Good food and good beer equals a good time and great potential.
So with Mississippi Craft Beer week on the radar the Golden Triangle is more than equipped to host any craft beer event. So which brewery or distributor wants to get their name out and promote craft beer? The Golden Triangle is more than ready for the task.
I don’t know if you follow me on Twitter (@wickdawg) or not and saw my tweet about two of my beers submitted to the National Homebrew Competition receiving 1st place. So as I prepare my beers for the final round submission I am going to document my lessons learned day by day as the deadline approaches.
Lesson Learned #5 - Patience
If you know me on a personal level, you know my patience comes and goes. It used to be around quite often, but here lately, patience has not been a virtue for me. I am reasoning as to why my patience is running a little thin right now. I couldn’t in my right mind think that I would have made it to the second round of National Homebrew Competition.
I’ve only been home brewing for a little over a year. The two beers that placed first were probably batch numbers 11 and 12, all grain batch numbers 2 and 3. As you could tell from my first lesson, I didn’t take very good notes, if any at all, so I’m not sure about the first numbers, but I know my Chocolate Hazelnut Porter was my second all grain batch and the brown was the third. So now I am trying to wait patiently for the two beers I brewed this past week to ferment out and get ready to be kegged. Here is the rough thing for me. Normally I wouldn’t worry about this so much, but next week I will be unable to rack my beers to the kegs. So I am going to have to do it on fermentation day 10 for the CHP and day 9 for the brown ale. Ten days of fermentation is about right. According to Jamil that is. Listening to his podcasts he says 10 days is normally when he knows things in your carboys are done what they needed to be done. So I’ll take a sample out of each and hope both of them went through the diacetyl rest, and rack to the keg and start carbonating those bad boys.
This post is mainly for me to RDWHHB (Relax, don’t worry, have a home brew).
<Deep Breath> - Ok, I’m good to go and ready for a home brew.
I don’t know if you follow me on Twitter (@wickdawg) or not and saw my tweet about two of my beers submitted to the National Homebrew Competition receiving 1st place. So as I prepare my beers for the final round submission I am going to document my lessons learned day by day as the deadline approaches.
Lesson Learned #4 - Brewing, while it’s fun, it can be a lot of hard work.
I enjoy brewing. I enjoy drinking the beer I brew. Prior to me not having that much confidence in my my home brewing skills, I brewed maybe once a month, twice if I was feeling frisky. I brewed 3 times in 5 days this past week. Twenty gallons (only 15 gallons of that is in my fermentation chamber). Needless to say, I’m whooped. Just plain tired. I work a full time job and to come home and whip up an all grain brew that evening is just plain crazy. Well, yes I am doing that now and I do not believe I’ll do it again. After this weekend, I’m solely a weekend/holiday brewer.
Now for a little tangent. Back in March my then finance now wife took a little trip to Maine for Shipyard’s Brewing Vacation (which she coined it a brewcation and told everyone at Shipyard that is what you need to call it, and that’s the law). It was an outstanding time in Maine. The weather was great, the scenery was gorgeous and the beer. Well, lets just say we had plenty of it. We arrive at Kennebunkport and check into our hotel and meet up with Shipyard’s Trade Brewer over a couple pints of chit chat and him letting us know what all we were going to be doing on the vacation. He also let us know we’ll need to report to the brewery at 6:30 the next morning and be ready to get our hands dirty and wet with some brewing. We were up for that task.
The next morning rolls along and we up and at ‘em and walking into Federal Jack’s brewery (which is the birthplace of Shipyard) and the Head Brewer there starts letting us know what all we were going to be doing. So we get to brewing, cleaning, more cleaning, and then some more cleaning. Needless to say it was a lot of hard work, we put in a 10 hour day, easy and he was sticking around to do more cleaning and paperwork after we finished up cleaning everything we were asked to clean.
So lets fast forward to this week. I know I’m not brewing a 7 barrel batch of beer. I get that. I am brewing a beer for myself, family and friends to enjoy. Oh yeah, and I’m brewing to ship off 6 beers to the National Homebrew Competition. I’ll walk you through the brew session for my Chocolate Hazelnut Porter.
My other half started heating my mash water up because she gets home well before me. So that saved me 30 minutes. So I arrive to mash water ready to go, so I pull out all of my equipment. First up, my converted 10 gallon water cooler, aka the mash tun. Since it was outside, I didn’t prime it with any hot water, it didn’t take long for it to heat up. I got the mash going. 5:38 is when I shut the lid and the clock started ticking away. So I got my yeast starter going for the beer. I had planned on pitching the next day anyways, due to my time constraints. Cleaned the brew kettle from the AHA big brew day. Then started the sparge water. Sent the wife to the store for the cocoa powder and more bar keepers friend. I recirculated some of the wort to set the grain bed for a good drain. Went and grabbed my sparge water threw it back into the tun. Let that rest for about 10 minutes. Recirculated again. Then drained. Got the kettle up onto the burner, then waited for the joker to come to a boil. Followed the hops schedule, added the cocoa powered in the last two minutes of the boil. I believe the time was around 9 by the time I turned the burner off and started the wort chiller. Well guess what, the hose clamps weren’t tight enough when I turned on the water. So I had a little leakage while getting the wort chiller going. Got that fixed then started chilling. My hydrangeas were happy to get a little extra water. Once I got to about 90 degrees, I got a cooler full of ice water, submerged a pond pump into that water, then hooked that up to my wort chiller and then I started recycling the water and added ice as needed to keep the water cold. So about 10pm is when the wort was cool enough to rack into my carboy. So I threw the carboy full of wort into my fermentation chamber and it would wait for my yeast to wake up and grow so it could ferment my beer nicely.
Then it was time to clean up. Rinse the mash tun, rinse out the kettle and put up all my odd and end things so it will be ready for the next day. Whew, lets just say, days later, I’m still whooped.
Lesson learned. Brewing is hard work. I know most home brewers dream of going pro. Wonder if they really realize how much work, mainly cleaning you do. A clean brewery makes good beer. So to make good beer, you need to be anal about having a clean brewery.
I don’t know if you follow me on Twitter (@wickdawg) or not and saw my tweet about two of my beers submitted to the National Homebrew Competition receiving 1st place. So as I prepare my beers for the final round submission I am going to document my lessons learned day by day as the deadline approaches.
Lesson Learned #3 - Yeast Viability
I have become adamant on using Jamil’s Yeast Pitching Rate Calculator (http://www.mrmalty.com). The last post I mentioned that I had a backup vial of WLP001 (California Ale) in my fridge. Well the best by date is May 14, 2011. Uh oh, the viability of that vial of yeast is going to be uber low. To figure out the production date of the the yeast, you subtract four months from the best by date. Well, that vial of yeast was produced on January 14, 2011 which Mr. Malty says the viability was at 16%. Well needless to say I am not using that vial of yeast. To pitch enough healthy yeast, I would need to to do a small started and feed it for a few days.
So here is my plan. I made starter wort last night and I am storing it in a sanitized gallon pickle jar. So once I get my mash going tonight I will get the stir plate fired up and build up some yeast and pitch tomorrow after work. That way the chocolate will have plenty of time to infuse into the wort. Maybe giving the beer a bit more chocolate flavor. Here’s to brewing!
Cheers!
As always you can contact me at wick at wickshomebrew dot com.
I don’t know if you follow me on Twitter (@wickdawg) or not and saw my tweet about two of my beers submitted to the National Homebrew Competition receiving 1st place. So as I prepare my beers for the final round submission I am going to document my lessons learned day by day as the deadline approaches.
Lesson Number 2 - Preparing for a Brew Session.
I wanted to show you that I do actually know how to use a hydrometer. At least I hope I do. So, yes AHA Big Brew day was a lot of fun. Didn’t realize it took so much longer to brew a 10 gallon batch than it does 5 gallons. More run off, heating more water, etc. Hey this is my lessons learned series and you are always learning while brewing.

Proof is in the pudding, uh, beer! So I really can’t tell ya the last time I’ve used my hydrometer, made notes on a brew day, etc. It was a successful brew day and I was successful in taking notes if I want to brew that beer again in the future.
So onto my next lesson learned. Living in a small town without a LHBS I cannot simply go to the store and pick up ingredients for my next adventure in home brewing. So luckily I have a couple reliable resources in Brewmasters Warehouse and Rebel Brewer and I can order in one day and get my supplies in the next day or two.
But there is much more for to plan out a brew day because of not having a local shop.
These are just some of the things I have to go through every time I do an order to an online home brew shop. Maybe I should take advice from the wifey and make lists. She is a list taking machine. One day I’ll learn.
The two recipes that placed, I ordered my supplies from Brewmasters Warehouse and their Brew Builder software saved the day. I just logged in and added those two recipes to the cart, went through my check list and boom, supplies ordered and I’m ready to brew. It’s really easy to use, you should go check it out.
I’m glad I keep a vial of White Labs California Ale on hand, just in case. Going to whip up that starter tonight and get it going, just in case my stuff arrives tomorrow and I’ll get to brewing as soon as possible. I’ll keep you updated.
You can contact me a wick at wickshomebrew dot com if you have any questions or comments.
I don’t know if you follow me on Twitter (@wickdawg) or not and saw my tweet about two of my beers submitted to the National Homebrew Competition receiving 1st place. So as I prepare my beers for the final round submission I am going to document my lessons learned day by day as the deadline approaches.
Lesson Number 1— TAKE GOOD NOTES! Especially if you enter your beers to competitions. I got really lazy and just wanted to brew and my notes on my beers that placed are lackluster at best. Why did I need to take notes? I still have the recipe.
Yes I still have the recipes, but do I know how much sparge water I used? What temperature the beers fermented at? No. All I know is that I fermented at ambient temps. But I have a newly acquired chest freezer that will serve as my fermentation chamber.
Take good notes. What was my final gravity? What was my efficiency? I have no clue. All I know, is that those beers were well received among my friends and that why I submitted them to NHC.
So with today being the AHA big brew day, I am going to start taking much better notes. At least I believe I’m going to. I need to take notes. We are brewing 10 gallons of the East India Pale Ale.
Be on the lookout for the next lesson learned.
Found in a book gifted to us called “The Jest Book” by Mark Lemon. It’s an old book. After some a Google search it seems to be published in 1909. Wow! The book is falling apart. Trying to be careful with it. But I wanted to share this “jest” with my beer friends.
CDXIX. — A Sudden Change.
ONE drinking some beer at a petty ale-house in the country, which was very strong of the hops and hardly any taste of the malt, was asked by the landlord if it was not well hopped. “Yes,” answered he, “if it had hopped a little further, it would have hopped into the water.”
I’m not sure how the kits are at Williams Brewing. But I feel quite sure there is not a home brew store that will steer you in the wrong direction. I personally haven’t ordered from Williams Brewing. The online home brew shops I frequent are, More Beer, Northern Brewer, Austin Homebrew, Midwest Supplies, Brewmasters Warehouse, and Rebel Brewer. Yeah that is a lot of shops, but I have received nothing but excellent customer service from all of these shops.
Good luck in your future brewing adventures. I am surely enjoying mine!